The video below was a class that I gave to the company's employees on
October 16, 2012. The goal is to explain the concept of rollover in the
forex market, which is synonymous with the term swap. The transcript is
below.
Shaun: Ok, so we're going to go over rollover and what it
is. It's really the interest that accrues for holding an open forex
position. When we place a trade, you guys know that we're trading on
leverage.
When we trade one lot of the EURUSD, we are trading
€100,000 and then we're selling whatever the equivalent is in USD at the
time. Right now the rate is 1.30. That means that we are buying
€100,000 and exchanging that for $130,000. This is when EURUSD is equal
to 1.3000.
Make sense so far? Unfortunately, everybody wants interest and they want
their pound of flesh. You're not just paying it for the money in your
account, you're actually owing interest and earning interest for the
positions that you have open. If you again use a current example,
interest rates are at historic lows. They use the overnight rate for
setting the rollover and swap rate on a position.The euro overnight
lending rate is set at 0.01%. It's basically free money.
The US
dollar has an overnight lending rate of 0.15%. These are annual rates.
It's pretty equivalent to what you're getting paid on a CD: almost
nothing. But, that goes have a cost associated with it. When you look in
MetaTrader, MT4 references it as the swap. In the industry, it's more
commonly known as rollover.
You have to pay interest for the
positions that you do have open because they have value. When we decide
to buy the EURUSD, that means that we own euros and we sold dollars. In
interest terms, that means that we are owed interest on the euros and we
owe interest on the dollars.
Chris: That would be bad because the US dollar is more?
Shaun:
Right. If you're buying the euro, and this is in magical fairy land
where you earn and pay the exact same amount of rollover for buying and
selling, and we'll get into exceptions in a minute, but in the "pure
scenario", you're only earning 0.01% annual interest on your euro
position. You're paying 0.15% interest on your dollar position. If
you're buying EUR/USD and held that position for a year, you would
expect to accrue a loss of 0.14%, which is the euro overnight interest
rate (0.01%) minus the dollar overnight interest rate (0.15%).
If you did the exact opposite and sold EUR/USD, you only owe 0.01% overnight interest, but you make 0.15% percent interest.
Chris: Are you assuming that you have the position open for an entire year?
Shaun:
Yes. Now, of course these rates change. These are overnight rates,
which means that over night they change on a daily basis. The amount
will fluctuate - slowly - but, it does fluctuate.
This is in the
hypothetical example where you bought EURSD, the overnight rates never
change and you held the position for precisely one year.
Chris: It's for one whole lot?
Shaun:
Yes. It's precisely one lot. One lot is the equivalent of 100,000 base
currency units. Our base currency here is the euro. 100,000 of the base
currency is 100,000 euros.
Let's go through and calculate the
rollover in our scenario of buying one standard lot of EURUSD. Apply the
0.01% rate to the €100,000 position. 0.0001 * €100,000 = €10. Of
course, you must put that back in dollar terms. €10 * $1.3000/€ (the
current exchange rate) equals $13. The $13 is the credit for the holding
the EURUSD position for an entire year.
The calculations are the
same for the dollar, except for the fact that it's now a debit. The
position of $130,000 * -0.015 (this is a negative number because we owe
it) equals... does anyone have a calculator on their phone? We all do;
we're programmers.
Andy: $195
Shaun: We have a $13 credit
and a $195 loss from the rollover. $182 is the amount of money that
we're going to lose after one year in our hypothetical scenario with the
EURUSD exchange rate not fluctuating, the overnight interest rates not
fluctuating and us holding our position for precisely one year.
The
next thing is that we need to go over the mechanics of rollover and how
it is charged. It's a little quirky. I'm stating the obvious, but there
are seven days per week.
Chris: What's with MB Trading only giving 50:1 leverage. What does that mean?
Shaun: It doesn't matter for the swap. If you have a position of €100,000, you owe interest on the €100,000.
Andy: You owe the interest on the leveraged amount?
Shaun:
Yes. It's on the leveraged amount. When we opened that €100,000
position, we did that with $2,000 on 50:1 leverage or $1,000 on 100:1
leverage. You're not paying or receiving interest on your margin amount.
You're paying or receiving it on the leveraged amount.
Chris: So if I were doing that with MB Trading, I'd have to do it with two lots?
Shaun: No. The interest is the same. You have a €100,000 position.
Chris: To leverage that much, don't I have to double my margin?
Shaun: Yes. Instead of using $1,000, now you use $2,000 to open the one lot trade.
Rollover
is seven days a week, but we know that trading doesn't happen on the
weekends. In forex, trading really happens from Sunday afternoon to
Friday afternoon. This is more of a technicality. The only really
important days are Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.They
need to charge interest for seven days even though there are only five
days that are important.
What they do is charge a single day of
interest on Monday, Tuesday, Thursday and Friday. By convention and for
no good reason, Wednesday's rollover carries the interest charges for
Wednesday, Saturday and Sunday.
Chris: Why don't they do it on Monday?
Shaun: I don't know. Why don't they do it on Thursday?
Terry: Or why don't they spread it out across the week evenly?
Shaun: Why don't you pay 1.5 days? That's just the way it is.
This is referred to as triple rollover Wednesday.
Andy: That's the for the past weekend, correct?
Shaun:
No. It has nothing to do with the weekends. Rollover occurs precisely
at 5 pm ET. When you look at the charts of most brokers, they are mostly
based on broker time. But in the forex industry by convention, 5 pm ET
is the start of a new day. 5 pm ET on Sunday is actually the start of
Monday. 5 pm ET on Monday is actually the start of Tuesday's trading
day. Tuesday's trading day concludes at 4:59 pm on Tuesday.
Andy: But on Wednesday, you get charged for the past Saturday and Sunday?
Shaun:
Even if you didn't have the trade open! If you decide - very poorly -
at 4:59 pm on Wednesday that you're going to open a trade, and you close
the trade two minues later at 5:01 pm on Wednesday, you are going to
earn or pay triple rollover.
Andy: Oh, so it has nothing to do with the last weekend. They just charge you three times for whatever happens on that day.
Shaun:
It's a market quirk. If you hold that position precisely at 5 pm, you
owe interest. If you do not, you do not owe interest. If you had the
trade open for 23 hours and 59 minutes, but you closed it before 5 pm,
no triple rollover. But if you have it at 5 pm, then you pay triple
rollover.
It's the same concept on Monday, Tuesday, Thursday and Friday, except it's only single rollover.
Chris: What's to keep people from finding a favorable currency comparison and just opening trades for two minutes every day?
Shaun: Lots of people try that and it doesn't work because of spread
costs. Notice that the rollover rates are so tiny. We're talking about
0.01% per annum. Divide that per day and it's a silly amount. It's so
negligible that you don't really care.
There are exceptions.
There's Golden Week and this involves the yen. There are days where
triple rollover Wednesday becomes nine times Wednesday. You earn the
interest for two weeks of trading.
Andy: Do brokers do that to get people to trade with them or something? Is that a for fun thing or is there an actual reason:
Shaun: It's because Japan shuts down for two weeks.
Chris: It's only in yen pairs?
Shaun:
Yes. Anything involving a yen pair in May has Golden Week where you
have a monster rollover day. It's kind of the way it is.
People do
try to take advantage of it. When interest rates were higher a couple
of years ago, there was a big differential between the pound and the
yen. The pound had an interest rate of 5.25% and the yen, as it is
today, had an annual interest rate near zero at 0.25%. I think today
that it's 0.1. The point is that there was a massive difference between
the two of 5%. You could earn that on the leveraged position.
Chris: Does that make the price spike?
Shaun:
Yeah, it does. People want to earn this money. This is what drives
currency market, the shift in the interest rates. People chase yield. If
I can open an account in GBP and I can earn 5.25%, if I'm holding yen,
that's looking really attractive to me.
I might consider the idea
of converting my yen into pounds so that I can the extra 5%. This is
referred to as a carry trade. It's the idea of using leveraged money to
earn the difference in the interest rates. It's possible and it can be
lucrative. The problem is that it depends on your timing of exchange
rates.
If you expect that... let me think of a scenario that
applies to today. Let's say that the ECB decides to reverse course, and
this is not likely to happen at all. Right now, they're trying to keep
their interest almost at zero. Let's say they decided to stop
intervening in the market and to charge a real interest rate. The euro
interest rate would go through the roof, which motivates people to put
their money into euros instead of dollars, yen, Australian dollars,
whatever. If you expect that trend to continue for several years, that
is a great motivation for buying that currency. Not only do you earn the
increasing differential in the two currencies' interest rates, but more
people are likely to follow the trade. The higher an interest rate is,
the more likely people are to buy that currency.
That was the
reason behind Brazil's hot market as of about two years ago. Interest
rates were 13-14% and everything was appreciating through the roof. You
could sit back and know that you were going to make 14% in reals. The
problem is that if you top the market like when the market yielded 14%,
you earned 14% in reals and then the price plummeted by 30%. Timing is
critical.
That's the fundamental reason that the market exists.
That's why people trade currencies. Not just for exchanges of payments,
but for speculation, that is entirely why people participate. It looks
like free money. There are all sorts of examples.
Oddly enough,
most of the mortgages in Poland are denominated in Swiss francs. The
reason is that the Swiss had a very, very low interest rate compared to
what the Polish zloty was charging at the time. If you could pay 0.5%,
why are you going to pay 5% interest to have it denominated in zlotys?
Well,
the reason is because the Swiss franc has been appreciating for several
years. Now half of Polish homeowners are severely underwater because
the value of their loans has appreciated by 20 or 30%. They only make
their income in zlotys. That's the risk of the market. Those are the
kind of real world examples of why people decide to participate and why
rollover is really important.
This is the electronic form of how
it applies to our traders and our customers speculating in markets. The
real mechanics behind it are more tangible like in the mortgage example.
Andy:
Is it common for strategies to keep track of I would make money, so I
want to hold my trade until I hit my interest point for the day?
Shaun:
You could, but it's a silly risk. If you think that it's dangerous to
be in now, you're going to stay in risking an average of 120 pips of
movement in the EURUSD so that you can capture the equivalent of 0.25
pips.
Andy: Ok, so it's pretty much worthless.
Shaun: Yeah.
Terry:
Your current interest rate, is that something that a strategy has
access to at the market level? Are we able to go out and query that?
Shaun: No.
Terry: So, it means that it has to be fed that values from some other source, which means...
Shaun: Nope. It has nothing to do with backtesting. It doesn't make assumptions about rollover. It isn't present in MetaTrader
on a historical basis. It is available in real time and I can show you
guys where to find that. It's not something that most people look at as
part of a strategy. It is an important part, but it shouldn't be the
maker or breaker. It should be a little bit of juice. You use it to pad
the margins a little bit or it might be a drag on performance. It should
not be the primary reason why you're entering a trade now at 4:59 pm
so that you can capture the tenth of a pip in interest cost and pay 2.5
pips in the process.
The one thing that I wanted to point out,
too, is that everything that I explained is kind of hypothetical. You
either lose 0.14% or you make 0.14% on an annual basis. In reality,
that's not how most brokers work. It's a good way that they pad their
margins.
This is how they make a slight amount of money on traders
that aren't trading, through the difference in the rollover rates that
they charge. In the example that I sent you, and assuming that we opened
MetaTrader and that it was a perfectly equal market, you would see that buying costs you. MetaTrader
shows you in dollars, but I'm just going to put it in percentages. You
expect a return of -0.14% for buying EURUSD and a return of +0.14% for
selling EURUSD.
What happens most of the time is that everything
gets skewed against you. The cost becomes a bigger number and the profit
becomes a smaller number.
Chris: You're saying it's the broker that does this?
Shaun:
Yes. It can be the broker or it can be the ultimate liquidity provider
behind the broker, but yes, the interest rates are set and then they get
shifted. Obviously, someone earns that differential.
Terry: So, obviously, these are within the bounds of legal priorities based on trading rules?
Shaun: Yes. It is a cost. I don't know of anybody that discloses it. I don't know who the ultimate beneficiary is to be honest.
Terry: It's the broker.
Shaun:
That's my assumption that the broker is making the difference. If they
net their trades, they should be capturing that difference. If you have
50,000 clients and most of them are piled into the EURUSD, there's only
going to be a certain amount of net exposure. Only say 10% of that
difference is going to be net long or short. You can net out the
difference between these two and keep all of it.
It's not super lucrative, but it's money sitting there and they take it.
Terry: A dime times 50,000 is lucrative.
Shaun: Yes. It adds up.
Terry: Especially when it's all electronic.
Shaun. Yes.
Chris: Maybe I'm behind the times, but I thought they were pressuring the euro zone to ease.
Shaun: They are.
Chris: But they're already way below the dollar.
Shaun.
Well, the target headline rate in the euro zone is 1.25%, which is the
result of the central bank intervening. They're buying Spanish bonds,
Italian bonds. Basically, the bonds that literally nobody wants. They're
buying them so that the interest rates go down.
If I'm going to
loan money, you have to make the call for your business or multinational
corporation. You have to decide. Do you want to tie up money in junk
debt for a year and get 6% in Spanish bonds? Or do you want to loan to
the ECB directly at 0.01%. You get paid almost nothing, but at least you
know you'll get your euros back.
Terry: Well, it depends on how
long you're planning on being in it and what you think the future is
going to turn. If you think that's going to turn, then go ahead and camp
on it now and get it for nothing.
Shaun: Right.
Terry: If you can afford to be in it that long.
Shaun: Yes, and that's why there are interest rate curves. That's a whole different subject.
If
you lend for a day, and let's use the US Treasury as the simplest
example, we start out with bills at the short end of the duration. Bills
are anything about a 90 day coupon and out to a year. You can buy a
treasury note for the one year, two year, five year and ten year. Each
duration is supposed to get higher and higher, but the further out you
go, you're supposed to get a higher rate of interest. It's rather
negligible compared to the duration. The difference between the
overnight and the 3 month is pretty substantial. The difference between
the 10 year and 30 year is supposed to be more substantial, but
obviously the time involved is almost beyond comparison.
That's why in the original EURUSD example I said that the overnight rate is this, because that's what we use in forex.
What people are really looking at when they're deciding whether or not
to take out mortgages or to loan money in different sovereign bonds,
they're looking at one year yields, ten year yields.
Terry: It seems like it doesn't make sense to go past ten years. Three decades is a long time to tie something up.
Shaun:
In that market I would agree, but there were people in the 1970s that
caught the US Treasury in the height of the stagflation when interest
rates in the US were at 17%. They loaned money when the short term rates
were actually inverted. People were taking the easy money earning 17%
annually over 3-6 months. The smart money locked up those interest rates
at 14% for thirty years. They made 14% per annum.
Terry: Compounded.
Shaun:
... compounded for 30 years. They guys that made the thirty years made a
killing and as close to risk free as you could get at the time.
Today, I would argue that's suicide. I don't think the dollar will be around in 30 years. But, that's a different story.
Andy:
When do these costs get calculated? Every day at 5 o'clock, they say
you gained two cents or whatever. When did that fee get charged.
Shaun:
Interest rates are a really complicated subject. They're actually the
result of a huge scandal right now that I know none of you know about,
none of the people that I know know about, but that everyone should be
up in arms about. It's called the LIBOR Scandal.
LIBOR is where
overnight interest rates are set. It's not a free market. It's voted on
by a group of 30 some-odd banks. It's all the normal culprits, the
people that are despised and rightfully so: the Goldman Sachs of the
world, Barclay's, RBS, Bank of America. Any bank that you've heard of
that's international, they're probably one of the banks that set the
LIBOR rates.
They all get to vote and decide what is tonight's
interest rate for the US dollar. When they set the rate, that's what
every bank in the world uses to set its overnight lending rate.
Chris: They just pull it out of thin air or they base it on something?
Shaun:
They pull it out of thin air. They just vote. There's a formulawhere
they throw out the most extreme votes and keep the average of the middle
ones.
It's the most important market in the world because it
affects everything that connects to money. It affects stocks, real
companies, bonds, mortgages, currencies... it affects everything.
What
happened this summer was that the Bank of England got caught
encouraging Barclay's to manipulate the LIBOR rate. As you can image,
banks have a strong interest in voting whether the LIBOR goes up or
down. It affects all sorts of things like how much they have to pay
savers in their CDs. How much do they charge for a mortgage. They have
all sorts of motivations to keep the interest rates as absolutely low as
possible to benefit themselves. That's what happened.
LIBOR is set in London, but it really doesn't matter. All the banks are international. It's really just a committee.
Andy: With no government oversight?
Shaun:
It was with the active collusion of the Bank of England and the Federal
Reserve. They encouraged the banks to keep the interest rates low
because it aligned with their policy objectives.
